 |
| A torn-down Framework 12.2 laptop next to a MacBook Neo |
In the world of consumer technology, few debates are as heated as the one between repairability and planned obsolescence. While Apple has long been criticized for making devices that are difficult to open and upgrade, the company recently surprised critics with the release of the MacBook Neo—a $599 laptop aimed at students that iFixit called its "most repairable laptop in 14 years."
But is "repairable" the same as "yours"? According to Nirav Patel, founder and CEO of Framework, the answer is a definitive no.
In a recent 33-minute teardown video posted to YouTube, Patel put Apple’s new budget-friendly MacBook Neo head-to-head against his company’s Framework Laptop 12. Both machines sit in the sub-$1,000 category, targeting students and light users. However, Patel argues that the similarities end at the price tag.
"There’s a simple idea that drives what we do," Patel states in the video. "A computer should be yours."
Two Laptops, Two Philosophies
Patel purchased a MacBook Neo directly from an Apple Store to see what was inside, comparing it side-by-side with the Framework Laptop 12, a 12.2-inch convertible touchscreen laptop that starts at the same $599 price point.
On the surface, the MacBook Neo represents a significant shift for Apple. It earned a repairability rating of 6/10 from iFixit, largely due to easy access to the touchpad, battery, and speakers. The ports can also be replaced without too much trouble.
However, once Patel began removing components, the "walled garden" became apparent. While the Neo offers some modularity, the keyboard requires users to peel off a layer of tape and unscrew 41 Phillips screws just to access it.
The real problem, however, lies in the components that matter most for longevity: the memory and storage.
Because the RAM and SSD are soldered to the motherboard on the MacBook Neo, buyers are essentially stuck with their initial configuration—whether that is 8GB of RAM or a fixed 256GB or 512GB of storage. If a user runs out of space or finds the machine too slow a year from now, there is no upgrade path.
In stark contrast, Patel’s teardown of the Framework Laptop 12 showed a motherboard clearly labeled with QR codes, parts connected via simple POGO pins, and a design philosophy that allows users to replace or upgrade nearly everything. From the motherboard and memory to the screen and keyboard, every component is designed to be swapped out in minutes.
If you are looking to build a setup that prioritizes longevity and customization, pairing a modular laptop with high-quality accessories is key. You can find recommended gear for a future-proof workspace here.
Patel highlighted this disparity specifically regarding screen damage. On the MacBook Neo, a broken display requires replacing the entire "top chassis"—a costly and complex repair. On the Framework, the display simply slides out and can be replaced in minutes.
The "Walled Garden" Strategy
Beyond the hardware teardown, Patel used the comparison to discuss the broader business strategies at play. He argued that Apple’s approach to the MacBook Neo isn’t just about selling a cheap laptop; it’s about customer acquisition.
"A big part of the MacBook Neo is to get new MacBook users right from the start and then bring them into the walled garden that Apple has created for them," Patel explained. "Once you’re a MacBook Neo owner, you run out of storage space, it gets a bit too slow, you need more ports, and you’re in the macOS world. Maybe you’ll buy that MacBook Pro or that MacBook Air at that $1,000, $2,000, or $3,000 price point."
He contrasts this with Framework’s mission, which is rooted in sustainability and consumer rights. Patel emphasized that schools—a key demographic for budget laptops—need repairability above all else to manage budgets and reduce e-waste.
"We want to eliminate that e-waste by making the product easy to use for as long as you want to use it," Patel said. "And of course, we don’t want this to be a stepping stone on the path to other computers. If you’ve got a Framework Laptop, we want you to be able to continue to upgrade it so that it works well for you for as long as you need it. That’s our entire philosophy."
A Shift in Consumer Sentiment
The release of the MacBook Neo and Framework’s response arrives at a time when consumers and governments are increasingly scrutinizing the lifespan of electronics. The right-to-repair movement has gained significant traction globally, pushing companies to make devices that last longer and are easier to fix.
While Apple’s Neo is a step forward for the company in terms of basic repairability, Framework’s Laptop 12 represents a leap forward in the concept of "ownership." By allowing users to swap out the motherboard to upgrade the CPU years down the line, Framework is attempting to break the traditional upgrade cycle that defines the consumer electronics industry.
For now, the choice for consumers boils down to a question of philosophy: do you want a laptop that is simply less difficult to repair, or one that is designed to evolve with you over a lifetime?
You can watch Nirav Patel’s full teardown and comparison on YouTube here.
Related Coverage: